Agentic AI Comparison:
DruAI vs HIA (Health Insights Agent)
vs
Introduction
This report provides a detailed comparison between HIA (Health Insights Agent), an open-source AI tool for analyzing blood report PDFs to deliver personalized health insights, and DruAI, enterprise AI agents from Druva focused on automating data security and cyber resilience workflows.
Overview
DruAI
DruAI refers to agentic AI agents integrated into Druva's enterprise data protection platform, designed to autonomously secure, recover, and manage data for cyber resilience. Targeted at businesses for automating workflows like backups and threat response. Part of a commercial SaaS offering from Druva, a established cybersecurity firm; no open-source availability or public pricing details found.
HIA (Health Insights Agent)
HIA is a free, open-source Streamlit application (MIT license) that enables users to upload blood test PDFs (up to 20MB), extracts text, and generates AI-powered health insights using a multi-model cascade via Groq (LLaMA-3.3-70B, LLaMA-3-8B, Mixtral-8x7B, Gemma-7B). It includes Supabase for secure authentication, session history, and a responsive UI. Deployable locally with Python 3.8+, requires API keys and database setup. GitHub repo has 12 stars, 6 forks.
Metrics Comparison
autonomy
DruAI: 9
Enterprise agents operate autonomously to handle data security, recovery, and management tasks end-to-end, minimizing human oversight in complex cyber resilience scenarios.
HIA (Health Insights Agent): 8
Features intelligent agent-based architecture with multi-model cascade, in-context learning, automatic PDF extraction, validation, and analysis workflow, requiring minimal user intervention beyond upload and auth.
DruAI edges out due to enterprise-scale automation; HIA is highly autonomous for its consumer health analysis scope.
ease of use
DruAI: 8
Integrated into Druva's SaaS platform for seamless enterprise use; simplifies complex cyber tasks without visible self-hosting needs, though likely requires admin configuration.
HIA (Health Insights Agent): 7
Streamlit provides modern, responsive UI with real-time feedback and simple upload process, but deployment requires technical setup (Git clone, env vars for Supabase/Groq, database schema).
DruAI likely easier for target enterprise users via SaaS; HIA accessible via hosted app (hiahealth.streamlit.app) but setup reduces score for self-deployment.
flexibility
DruAI: 5
Proprietary enterprise solution locked to Druva platform and cyber resilience use cases; limited public info on customization or extensibility beyond vendor support.
HIA (Health Insights Agent): 9
Open-source (MIT), self-hostable, customizable code structure (agents, services, prompts), supports multiple AI models with fallback, extensible for other report types.
HIA far more flexible as open-source; DruAI rigid for specific enterprise data protection needs.
cost
DruAI: 4
Commercial enterprise SaaS from Druva with subscription pricing (details undisclosed); high cost expected for business-scale cyber resilience features.
HIA (Health Insights Agent): 10
Completely free (open-source MIT license); operational costs only for Groq API usage and optional Supabase (free tier available).
HIA wins decisively on zero software cost; DruAI suits budgets with enterprise ROI justification.
popularity
DruAI: 7
Backed by established Druva (cybersecurity leader); press release indicates enterprise rollout, listed among agentic platforms, implying stronger commercial traction.
HIA (Health Insights Agent): 3
Early-stage project with 12 GitHub stars, 6 forks, 1 watcher; featured on AI Agent Store (51% metric?) and Streamlit forum, but low adoption metrics.
DruAI more popular in enterprise context; HIA niche and emerging in open-source AI health tools.
Conclusions
HIA excels in flexibility and cost as a free, customizable open-source health analysis tool ideal for individuals, developers, or small-scale deployment, scoring highest overall (37/50). DruAI leads in autonomy, ease of use, and popularity for enterprise cyber resilience (33/50), but its proprietary nature limits accessibility. Choose HIA for personal/affordable health insights; DruAI for professional data security automation.